Which aspect of Jonathan Edwards' preaching caused a division among Puritans?

The aspect of Jonathan Edwards' preaching that caused a significant division among Puritans was his focus on emotion. Edwards is known for his passionate and emotional style, especially exemplified in his famous sermon "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God." His approach sought to evoke strong feelings of fear, dread, and a sense of urgency about personal salvation, which contrasted with the more rational and intellectual styles preferred by some Puritans. This emotional appeal stirred debate about the proper way to experience and express faith.

While theological debates, the conflict between predestination and free will, and the influence of Pietism were certainly relevant issues within Puritan communities, it was Edwards' emphasis on emotional experience in faith that notably contributed to a fracture among Puritans. This division reflected broader tensions within the spiritual landscape of early America, where some clung to a more traditional, austere form of worship, while others embraced a more fervent, emotionally charged connection with God.